“I hate you!” (Its nothing personal…)
A boy and his mother walk into Macy’s. The lanky lad, who looks to be about 15, walks a few paces ahead. Although they share similar facial features, their expressions are vastly different.
The look he throws about says, “Let’s just get this over with.”
Hers says, “We haven’t spent time together in awhile. This is kind of nice.”
I watch them intently. It is the winter of 2002. My little boy is 6 months old. I find myself seeking out and studying the dynamics between mothers and sons. No matter the age or life stage of the parties, their interactions fascinate me.
Within a few seconds, the skulking young man is navigating through the women’s section and moving toward the escalator. His mother silently follows. Then she sees a brightly colored sweater. She stops a second to admire the sweater, to touch the material before she calls out to him.
Upon hearing his name, the boy stops in his step, rolls his eyes, then turns around and walks back to his mom.
“What do you think of this sweater?” she asks, holding it to her shoulders. “I really like this color.”
“Whatever mom. I don’t care.” He uses an irritable tone, emphasizing the last three words. He starts to slowly walk away.
She winces at the remark. She hangs her head as she slowly puts the sweater back on the rack. She gives it a final smoothing then walks quickly to catch up with her son.
The “weary breastfeeding mother who’s neck-deep in diapers” in me is tempted to grab him by the shoulders and admonish him. I want to point out the injustice he’s done to his mother. I want to command him to respect her. I want to point out the sacrifices she’s made, the nights she’s comforted him, the meals she’s fed him and the countless little things she’s done for him to show her love.
I’ve thought of that memory alot as the years have passed. As the relationship between Seth and me slowly changes, my perspective of that incident evolves as well. Now, I see this boy’s actions as something less personal. He is, in an incredibly awkward and painful way, trying to assert his independence. He aspires to be his own man. While he does not want to need his mother, she knows he still does.
I hope his mother, after a few minutes, realized that his indifference wasn’t really about her. I hope she realized he was in the middle of uncharted territory with limited life experience. He was dealing with this separation process the only way he knew. He didn’t stop to think about his actions or how this process affects his mother. But, to be honest, how many of us at that age have?
I may be completely wrong in my theories. I’ve never mothered a teen boy, nor have I been one so really, what do I know? I write this in case I’m right. Because I hope that in 10 years, I can remember “its not personal” myself.






Alissa on 21 Dec 2007 at 12:56 pm #
Oh, I know. Sometimes, even at the ages of 4 and 6, my boys say the meanest things. And I have to remind myself that they’re just trying to be themselves, that someday they’ll live without me just fine. But I also know that, when they treat me like that at the age of 16, I will be hurt. I’ll get over it, but it’ll hurt–personal or not.
Alexandra on 21 Dec 2007 at 2:15 pm #
I think we all go through that phase where we think our parents are so LAME… That kid is 20 now, probably in college, and calling mom and dad every week for money! I bet he’s changed his tune now!
christina_the_wench on 21 Dec 2007 at 2:27 pm #
Its’ not. Although obviously not a male, I remember treating my mom poorly as a teen and thinking back now, it wasn’t personal. I think all teens go through that “god, my parents are so lame!” stage and the independence-acquiring thing.
Seth will love you even if he pretends you are some bag lady hassling him in Kohl’s. Try to remember that.
Merry Christmas, Lisa!
Julie on 21 Dec 2007 at 2:45 pm #
When I discovered I was having a boy, I thought about this stuff a lot, too. I think you’re right — it’s all about independence. I look at my husband now and how much he loves his family and how thankful he is for everything they do for him and I think, “now there’s a kid who gave his mom hell as a teenager, and he turned out OK.”
HollowSquirrel on 21 Dec 2007 at 3:21 pm #
I’ve been that teenage boy. Well, without the penis. And chest hair. And I still feel badly about the behavior which made my mom feel bad. It wasn’t intentional… just hormonal almost.
I’m glad you can remember this as your cutie grows. Now stop writing posts that make me tear up.
HUGS to you and your cute boys!
flutter on 21 Dec 2007 at 3:37 pm #
Oh but the heart feels different, doesn’t it?
Ree on 21 Dec 2007 at 4:38 pm #
You, my dear, are going to be a great mother of a teenager. I live with this every other day. On the opposite days? He’s a dream. I have to remind myself constantly….it’s not me.
Heidi on 21 Dec 2007 at 6:58 pm #
We’re all going to need to remember that sooner or later. Thank goodness we have the blogosophere to support and help us!
Heidi
ABunsLife on 21 Dec 2007 at 7:29 pm #
Since YOU are a great mom it won’t be personal. Quit looking that far into the future and enjoy the cute lovable stage he is in now!!!
Oh, The Joys on 22 Dec 2007 at 2:52 am #
I think I am going to struggle like crazy during this phase. I’ll get my feelings hurt for sure.
Chick on 22 Dec 2007 at 1:16 pm #
Right now my son thinks I’m the best thing since white ice cream and Pokemon.
I’m not sure how he’ll feel in a few years.
I’m scared, actually.
Linda on 23 Dec 2007 at 4:15 am #
That 15-year-old boy at Macy’s is my son! Not literally, but the attitude is sure familiar — and I think you nailed the reasons. Tonight, my hubby and I persuaded him to walk with us for a family time relaxing and checking out the neighborhood Christmas lights. After about fifteen minutes, our son decided to do his walking across the street from us! Some days he acts 30 years old, and other times he acts 10. As you say so well, that adolescent in-betweenness is “incredibly awkward and painful.”
But I have to say the “snow penis” post created a great mother-son bonding moment of doubling over in giggles! Thanks!
angela on 23 Dec 2007 at 4:37 am #
Ahh teenagers. I’m pretty sure I pulled that whole indifference card myself a time or two in those days.
Dana on 23 Dec 2007 at 4:41 am #
Oh…this is a beautifully written post — it brought a tear to my eye. Mostly because my youngest brother often treats our mom this way — and also because I worry that Dawson will turn out like this. I suppose it really isn’t personal and I have to remember that.
Sugared Harpy on 24 Dec 2007 at 12:26 am #
I haven’t really had this issue with the boys (yet), and they are 11 and 13. But I wonder if it’s because I am aware that I am so past the point of picking out stuff for them, that I want them to have opinions about things, or just that they are maybe more gentle when they say they don’t like something.
They never say anything snotty about a suggestion, they just say, “No, thank you. How about THIS one? With the skulls?”
Kristin on 24 Dec 2007 at 2:50 am #
As the mother of 2 tween age boys I can tell you that the sulking-pouting-misery-is-my-middle-name ‘tude is part and parcel… mine are still pretty nice because I don’t tolerate the RUDE… but man, is it hard sometimes!
Heidi on 24 Dec 2007 at 6:24 pm #
Hmm…very astute observations. I don’t know if I would have been able to see it from the boy’s perspective as you did…only would have sympathized with the poor mommy. It’s amazing what becoming a mother does to one! A few years back I would have been sympathizing with the boy!
corky4208 on 28 Jan 2008 at 1:26 am #
I am in a terrible place with my 12 year old son. He transitions between his dad (Buddy) and me (Dickhole) every other week. He often says he hates me and our house and calls me the above name. He gets so angry over my even opening my mouth. All I have to say is, “What do you mean?” and he springs like a cobra. His dad and I have been divorced for 11 years and recently the dad has forced the 50/50 custody situation. I don’t agree, but he’s convinced my son that anything else is unfair. It has to do with financial support, but I am helpless because my son loves to be with him, and has left an open threat that if I “do anything to screw it up…”. He doesn’t like the stepmother, but tells me he has learned to live with it. Conversely, he tells me that if I were to ever meet someone, he would do everything in his power to ruin it. I haven’t gone down that path. I totally think that any child needs a close relationship with Dad, but Son’s relationship with me is completely unhealthy. Dad originally left the marriage because it got in the way of dating (including my best friend) but Son knows nothing about it. I’m really close to laying it all out for him because I can’t stand the rejection from my son when I have always been there for him and Dad wrecked everything, including the fact that he has no siblings. Dad has filled in more and more only because Son is now older and more fun and circumstances have changed, including a change in financial situation through marriage. I do not try to compete with “more fun”. Son and I have huge fights because I will not tolerate rudeness and disrespect. That’s usually when I hear that I am hated and called the fancy name. I know I am doing the right thing: not competing with the “better” house, not tolerating attitude, recognising manipulation, etc. but Son is amazingly well behaved with all others, is captain of his teams and adored by everyone. It’s only behind closed doors with me that he acts like a complete loonie. He’s gone at the end of the week, unfortuately, and so everything is always left undone. The days he arrives and the days he leaves are always the worst, which could be predicted. I am pretty close to beating him.